It’s logical to assume what happened here was a deliberate violation of immigration lawyer Andrew Lattarulo’s rights. The problem is that even deliberate violations need to be litigated. The ruling here paves the way for Lattarulo to continue his lawsuit against immigration officers who violated his rights. Unfortunately, winning here just generates another on-ramp to roads littered with insurmountable jurisprudence roadblocks.
But let’s not dwell on the potential futility of this lawsuit and instead dig into a decision where a federal judge has bucked the Supreme Court’s desire to excuse and all federal officers from accountability. This ruling finds in favor of someone whose rights were violated, rather than automatically assuming precedent demanded immediate dismissal. (h/t Kyle Cheney)
Early on in the decision [PDF], you can clearly see why immigration officers decided to engage in punitive action against Lattarulo. It’s not just that Lattarulo regularly defended people ICE wanted to make disappear, but he also actively informed other migrants of their rights via viral-esque videos:
Andrew Lattarulo is an immigration lawyer and part owner of the law firm Georges Cote LLP, which represents “thousands of clients in active immigration proceedings.” Lattarulo also runs a popular Instagram account featuring videos of himself discussing “know-your-rights information about U.S. immigration matters,” [id. ¶ 59], which regularly “amasses hundreds of thousands of views…”
At some point, this lawyer and the law firm drew the attention of Trump’s anti-migrant forces. This led to normally unimaginable legal action by the Trump administration. The DHS’s Homeland Security Investigations (HSI) unit claimed the Cote law firm employed undocumented migrants. It demanded the firm turn over documentation on its employees — a demand the Cote law firm apparently complied with.
While HSI went through the motions of trying to find literally any reason at all to shut down a law firm that provided zealous representation to detained migrants, Lattarulo and his employer decided to spend the weekend in Aruba. Cote returned from this trip and went through customs without incident.
Things went way worse for Lattarulo when he returned from the same weekend trip:
When his flight arrived at Logan Airport, three U.S. Customs and Border Protection (“CBP”) agents and one HSI officer stopped Lattarulo as he got off the plane. The agents seized his cell phone without a warrant and then downloaded a complete copy of the data stored on the phone. Eight days later, they returned the cell phone via overnight delivery.
What’s on the record suggests the government did this not because it was essential to its border-securing work but simply because it could, given that it happened in one of the nation’s many constitutional dead zones, which not cover any international airport but anything up to 100 miles inland from any physical border crossing.
Supposedly, the government has not yet performed a search of the seized phone. But it definitely intends to… or at least believes it can work its way backwards from an unconstitutional search via any of the handy Get-Out-of-Lawsuit-Free cards the courts have provided it over the years.
The seized cell phone data is currently in a format that is not readable or reviewable, but the government intends to convert the data to an accessible format and search it if the Court permits.
The data includes confidential information, including privileged attorney-client communications related to Lattarulo’s clients.
So, there’s more than Lattarulo’s First Amendment rights at stake here. But if the government wants to engage in deliberate violations of attorney-client privilege, it first needs to convince a court that the seizure of Lattarulo’s phone has nothing to do with his immigration law work or his popular Instagram account that discusses these same legal issues.
Thus far, it’s not working out for the government. As the court notes in its discussion of the case, there is “no dispute” that Lattarulo’s public statements via his Instagram account (which include criticism of government policies and practices) are protected by the First Amendment. What needs to be demonstrated is that the seizure of the lawyer’s phone would likely not have happened if he hadn’t engaged in this criticism of the government.
This sure looks like illegal retaliation against this lawyer, says the Court. Before even getting to the matter of the phone seizure itself, the court points out that HSI aggressively accelerated its “investigation” of the law firm — trimming the response time for the firm to turn over documents from the stated ten days to less than three days, apparently for the sole reason of giving it a justification for the seizure of the lawyer’s phone upon his return to the United States.
Furthermore, if the government was truly interested in securing information from the law firm, rather than just looking for an excuse to seize an immigration lawyer’s phone, it would had detained the head of the law firm (Georges Cote) and demanded access to his devices upon his arrival in the US a full day before Lattarulo’s plane landed. That HSI showed no interest in Cote — despite him being the ostensible target of its illegal employment investigation — makes it abundantly clear this was all about the government finding some way to punish Lattarulo for his speech and, possibly, illicitly gain access to his communications with ICE detainees.
The government asked the court to not only reject this lawsuit but to apply a “bright line” ruling stating that anything the government pretends to be “reasonable suspicion” is sufficient to excuse any resulting rights violations. The court says lol no, that won’t be happening.
Defendants seek a bright-line rule that because they had reasonable suspicion to conduct the search, Lattarulo cannot show that retaliation was a but-for cause. [Opp’n at 14–15]. The Court disagrees.
[…]
[T]he limited record before the Court suggests that searches of cell phones are not regularly conducted during the kind of employment investigation at issue here and that Lattarulo’s own law firm partner was not subjected to the same seizure and search of property. The presence of reasonable suspicion therefore does not categorially bar a finding of causation under Nieves.
The court also addresses some of the Fourth Amendment concerns generated by HSI and ICE’s actions. While it’s not willing to rule on this issue (yet), mainly because these violations flow from the initial First Amendment violation, it doesn’t let them pass without comment.
The question this case raises is: reasonable suspicion of what? In other words, what types of suspected criminal activities can the government use a warrantless advanced border search to investigate? The First Circuit in Alasaad stated that the exception applies to searches for “contraband” or for “evidence of contraband or a border-related crime.”
[…]
The difficulty of this case lies in the fact that the suspected violation at issue—employment of unauthorized aliens in the United States in violation 8 U.S.C § 1324a—involves a law that is “enforced or administered by CBP or ICE” but arguably is not a “border-related crime.” Based on the information before the Court, there appears to be no connection between Lattarulo’s border crossing (or, more broadly, the government’s interest in policing the border) and the suspected crime that formed the basis for the government’s border search. Rather, it appears that the government seized on a fortuitous border crossing following a weekend vacation as an opportunity to search for evidence of a domestic crime it was already investigating.
At the end of the day, the court finds in favor of the Constitution. Since the phone has already been returned to Lattarulo, the court doesn’t need to do much else other than forbid HSI from looking through the content it downloaded from the lawyer’s phone until further notice. Given what’s stated here, “further notice” will likely take the form of a ruling ordering the government to destroy the data it copied from the lawyer’s phone. If we’re lucky, the government will appeal this and end up creating even more precedent that works against it.
Until then, the government is on notice that this sort of stuff won’t fly, even when it’s happening in “Constitution-free zones” where a majority of US citizens reside, or — at the very least — pass through on a daily basis.