SF Public Defender Mano Raju Hits Appeals Court, Defends Decision to Limit Caseload

Posted
SF Public Defender Mano Raju Hits Appeals Court, Defends Decision to Limit Caseload

San Francisco Public Defender Mano Raju appeared in court on Thursday to contest a contempt ruling and related $26,000 fine issued for refusing to take on some felony cases brought to his office. Raju argued his decision is the result of crushing workloads his office already faces on a daily basis.

As KTVU reports, Raju was in court to argue against an earlier ruling by San Francisco Superior Court Judge Harry Dorfman, who ordered his office to pay a penalty of $1,000 each for 26 separate acts of contempt. Those charges came in May 2025 after Raju decided to stop accepting every case assigned by the court.

His reasons: an already-overworked staff, a lack of funding, and the rising numbers of felony cases being brought by the District Attorney's Office over the previous year. Given the Public Defender's Office is legally mandated to represent any client who requires representation but cannot afford it, Raju's bold gambit has not been well-received by the courts.

In his decision, Judge Dorfman ruled that the Public Defender's Office did, in fact, have enough attorneys to take on the assigned caseload.

On Thursday, Raju and his legal counsel, Kory DeClark, appeared in California's 1st District Court of Appeal in San Francisco to present oral arguments in appeal of Dorfman's decision. The office's fine, per KTVU, has been stayed by the court pending the outcome of this current appeal.

Arguments made by DeClark to the court include citing a California Penal Code statute concerning the obligation of the state to provide alternative counsel if the Public Defender's Office is unavailable. DeClark also argued that the court bears responsibility for not collecting enough data about caseloads being handled by Raju's office prior to determining that they did in fact have enough attorneys available.

Speaking with press after his court appearance, Raju called for more funding for his office.

"If we are going to have a society that chooses to arrest and prosecute this many people, then we have to fund public defense," Raju said. "Otherwise, you have people waiting, as I said before, for weeks, months, or years for their day in court. You have wrongful convictions that can happen. You have people being separated from their families, and it doesn't just impact the people that we're representing."

KTVU further reports that the day before his court hearing, public defenders from 36 California counties — including Alameda, Marin, Santa Cruz, Santa Clara, Contra Costa, Napa, Solano, Mendocino and Monterey — collectively issued a joint statement in support of Raju.

California's 1st District Court of Appeal is expected to issue a ruling within the next 90 days.

Related: Huge Spike in SF Criminal Trial Cases Prompts Audit, Bogged-Down Courts to Release Some Defendants

SF News, mano raju, sf public defender